Home page
SPONSOR AD

Support our Vendors!  |  Advertise Here

Topic: Crate Engine or heads and cam

in Forum: C3 Engines


Already a Member?
Login
Not yet a Member?
Register for Free!

Back to Forum List
New TopicNew Topic-Locked
ReplyReply-Locked
New PollNew Poll-Locked
Search
Hide Signatures
Crate Engine or heads and cam (1/15)
 3/20/07 4:56am
KeBo
Former Member

Send Private Message

Kendall Park, NJ - USA

Vette(s):
1981 - 59 Beige over Cinnebar leather. Edlebrock top end, 2200 stall w/shift kit, 3:55s, Mufflex maniback exhaust, nice stereo, 16 in AREs w/BFGs


Joined: 3/9/2005
Posts: 789

Just dreamin, dont know if I could afford to do this at this point but figured I'd ask...  My 81 has the trans and rear done (3:55s).  Im dreaming or thinking about ETs now..  My car is street driven, it will never see a track.  But, my Moms Camry will take it..  LOL...  Do I change the heads and cam or should I just think of a crate motor? 
 
The important part is the car has to be VERY streetable, no heating issues (My cooling system is brand new) and have no relyability issues.
 
My mechanic who I love and really knows his stuff said just to drop in a ZZ4.  Heres where I get confused... A complete zz4 is 4500.00 carb to pan.  I'm seeing engine builders offer dyno verified 385hp for 3200.00.
 
Whats everyones thoughts on a crate motor?  Should I look at a head and cam swap? 
 
What is a real budget on this and any ideas on real 1/4 and 60 sec time..
 
THANKS!   
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Our Sponsors help support C3VR
Crate Engine or heads and cam (2/15)
 3/20/07 5:06am
Adams' AppleLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Moderator
Send Private Message

Duncanville, TX - USA

Vette(s):
#1-1974 L-48 4spd Cp Med Red Metallic/Black deluxe int w/AC/tilt/tele./p/w-p/b/ Am-Fm/map light National/Regional/Chapter NCRS "Top Flight" #2-1985 Bright Red/Carmine Cp.L-98/auto Member: NCRS, NCRS Texas, Corvette Legends of Texas


Joined: 11/8/2003
Posts: 20201

Compared to what is available as "crate" these days, a head/cam swap on a low compression engine doesn't look like a money saver. It may be cheaper to go with a top end swap, but I don't think the performance gain would make it comparable to a crater in the end. Just my .02

______________

Joel Adams
C3VR Lifetime Member #56    

My Link


(click for Texas-sized view!)
             NCRS

"Money can't buy happiness -- but somehow it's more comforting to cry in a CORVETTE than in a Kia"

Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (3/15)
 3/20/07 5:20am
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

On a dollar for dollar basis, a crate engine is the way to go. You can buy them in many power levels, plus they have a warranty on them.

I'm not saying you can't get a 385hp engine for $3200, but that's probably a lowball figure, unless you do your own work and have access to a machine shop.

The entire engine is no stronger than its weakest parts. If you add new heads and a cam, your lower rotating assembly is still old and has some wear, so you won't get the maximum potential out of the buildup, unless you rebuild the entire engine.

You have to assume your block needs to be bored out...lots of machine time and labor plus new pistons...not cheap for quality work. New heads are a good idea either way you decide to go...a lot of money spent on your existing heads is better spent on new aluminum ones. Your crank would have to be polished...more shop time and labor.

A new crate engine also takes advantage of modern casting techniques and is very high quality, not that your original engine isn't. The new castings are generally somewhat lighter in weight. You can either save your original engine, or sell it to help offset the costs of the new engine.

You still have to remember that more horsepower creates more heat...you still might have to upgrade your new cooling system.

Also, and I know this adds significantly to the overall investment...think fuel injection. It's not a necessity by far, but you won't regret it in the long run.
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (4/15)
 3/20/07 6:03am
jayare
Former Member

Send Private Message

Joined: 1/4/2007
Posts: 475

Go get yourself one of those Camry engines....Your Vette is lighter weight so i'll bet you can take her Clown
 
Seriously......Go to www.gmpartsdirect.com and look over the crates. The sale may still be on.Thumbs%20Up
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (5/15)
 3/20/07 1:18pm
aceintheholeLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

Manteca, CA - USA

Vette(s):
1978,two tone,Metalic Rootbeer & gold 1975 L48 4 speed


Joined: 11/20/2005
Posts: 3623

WoW ! Sure can't beat those prices.

______________

Jimmy B.
Just can't wait to get on the road again.

 
                             Click to see larger views!

Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (6/15)
 3/20/07 4:51pm
gurtz
Former Member

Send Private Message

baton rouge, LA - USA

Vette(s):
1981 dark metallic blue, dark doeskin leather interior, mirrored glass T Tops, 330hp/350ci GMPP crate engine, billeted aluminum serpentine system, Dewitts with dual spalls


Joined: 8/12/2006
Posts: 391

KeBo:
 
I did the same investigation and I listened to my mechanic's advice and I based it off of what Gunslinger is saying.  You and I both have the 2 bolt main 350 ci stock GM motor.  I pulled my original motor, took het apart and she is bathing in oil.
 
I did not put the ZZ4 because of the hood issue.  My wife and better half, the fine young Cajun Girl she is, is only 5 ' tall and could not see over the stock hood, so I X'ed the ZZ4, but what a setup.  If I only knew she was not going to drive the Vette anymore, I would have installed the ZZ4 or 383 stroker with the new hood.
 
I put the GM330 hp and I am very pleased ,two buds and I did it one weekend.  I was getting horrible performance out of the stock 8-8.5 mpg.  I got almost 16 this weekend with a turbo 350 tranny.  You pretty much know what your budget is with the crate!
 
My.02, LOL 
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (7/15)
 3/21/07 5:19am
Sarge81Lifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

WEST SENECA, NY - USA

Vette(s):
1981 Blue Ice Met. w/pearl ghost flames TKO500 5speed. LS1 Swap 3.45 Dana 44.


Joined: 12/3/2001
Posts: 2379

Crate engine Thumbs%20Up
 
I still have the original engine mothballed in the corner of the garage. It wasn't worth rebuilding. I started with a GM 350 HO 330hp crate engine and have done some tinkering with it to improve it a little. A friend of mine awhile back put a ZZ4 in his '80 L-82 vette. That car moved pretty good.


______________

GEN III 5.7L "LS6" Engine swap
TKO500 5 spd.
3.54 Dana 44
'69 "N11" Sidepipes
Borgeson Steering Box
Born 8/1981
Sequence #3975




Click here to see more pics of my Vette on CarDomain.


Lifetime Member #26
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (8/15)
 3/21/07 5:43am
KeBo
Former Member

Send Private Message

Kendall Park, NJ - USA

Vette(s):
1981 - 59 Beige over Cinnebar leather. Edlebrock top end, 2200 stall w/shift kit, 3:55s, Mufflex maniback exhaust, nice stereo, 16 in AREs w/BFGs


Joined: 3/9/2005
Posts: 789

Gurtz, Darryl; My motor is actually in great shape.  I have 65k on it.  My main reason for the change is only to improve performance.
 
Can I ask a favor of you guys..  Can I have the specs/model id on your motors and if you dont mind, can you tell me where you bought them.  Gurtz, your motor pix are gorgeous!  Im not going to change any panels..  Other question for you guys, what headers/manifolds did you use?  I have a big dollar exhaust system hooked up to the stock manifolds. 
 
 
Lastly - tell me im nuts, check out Aandnengines, you can catch them on Ebay same name..  They have a nice street motor for 3295.00 408hp(it looks net)
 
Thanks for your help.. 
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (9/15)
 3/21/07 7:08am
warbird
Former Member

Send Private Message

Roseland, NJ - USA

Vette(s):
1974, 454 with 4 on the floor, matching numbers.


Joined: 12/4/2003
Posts: 966

Kevin,
Nothing goes as planned, especially with a Vette. I went with the cam, lifters, rollers manifold, carb, etc. The whole thing was supposed to cost around $3,000.
By the time it was done it cost very close to $5,000 ! Don't get me wrong I'm very pleased with the performance, but if I knew then what It was going to cost me I would have gotten a crate engine and saved the original.
Just my 2 cents
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (10/15)
 3/21/07 9:44am
KeBo
Former Member

Send Private Message

Kendall Park, NJ - USA

Vette(s):
1981 - 59 Beige over Cinnebar leather. Edlebrock top end, 2200 stall w/shift kit, 3:55s, Mufflex maniback exhaust, nice stereo, 16 in AREs w/BFGs


Joined: 3/9/2005
Posts: 789

Octavio, Oh yeah, NOTHING ever goes as planned!  My rear went from 2500.00 to 4200.00.  I hear rthe budget, add 25% and pray..  LOL...
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (11/15)
 3/21/07 10:35am
jrflyboyVP2
Former Member

Send Private Message

Austin, TX - USA

Vette(s):
73 coupe bought new in 1973 with only luggage rack, AM/FM radio, HD battery & Maplight as options. L48, 4 speed, Paint Med Met Blue 922 interior Dark saddle 418 special order. Repurchased 4/1/06 after 24 years.


Joined: 3/27/2006
Posts: 104

I have a question concerning crate motors.  gmpartsdirect.com lists the LM1 350 engine at 250hp/304ftlb for $1,292, and the HP 290/350 with 290hp/326ftlbs for $1652.  Both need intake, carb, distributor, starter, waterpump, ect.  Anyone know what the difference is in these two engines which accounts fo the 16% increase in HP.  Is it just a different cam, or are the heads different?  Would it be better to buy the LM1 and use the $360 difference to replace the cam, and pocket the difference.
 
John
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (12/15)
 3/21/07 12:18pm
Gunslinger
Former Member

Send Private Message

Frederick, MD - USA

Vette(s):
1969 convertible L71 427/435 4-speed black interior


Joined: 9/8/2003
Posts: 3398

Same head specs...same compression ratio...different camshaft...different crankshaft. Both have 4-bolt mains on the crank. The 290hp has a nodular iron crankshaft (stronger) where the other has a cast crank.

If you buy the LM1 and change the cam, you'll lose the warranty since you modified it.

Depending on your finances, give thought to the 350HO/330hp engine. It gives the most bang for the buck.
Reply-LockedReply-Locked
Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
Crate Engine or heads and cam (13/15)
 3/21/07 4:08pm
stingrayjim jrLifetime Member
Lifetime Member
Send Private Message

SHELBYVILLE, TN - USA

Vette(s):
1976 L48 auto

1978 L82 4speed

1994 LT1 6speed


Joined: 7/5/2002
Posts: 3942

I'd gotten my zz4 from Jeg's ... complete engine minus starter/carb/exhaust/etc.... best i recall, was around $3800, but that was 4 years ago...or was it 5?... anyhow i'll paste the specs
 
  • 355 HP @5250 RPM, 405 FT.LBS of Torque @ 3500 RPM (Max. Recommended RPM: 5800)
  • 10.1:1 Compression Ratio
  • Cast Iron 4-Bolt Block with One-Piece Rear Main Seal
  • Forged Steel Crankshaft
  • High Silicon Aluminum Pistons w/Offset Pins
  • PM Steel Connecting Rods
  • Aluminum Angle Plug 58cc Chamber Cylinder Heads w/ 1.94'' Int./ 1.50'' Exh. Valves
  • Steel Hydraulic Roller Cam, Lift: .474'' Int./ .510'' Exh., Duration @ .050: 208° Int./ 221° Exh.
  • 1.5 Ratio Rocker Arms
  • Aluminum Dual Plane Intake Manifold
  • HEI Distributor
  • 8'' High-RPM Torsional Damper
  • Cast Iron Water Pump
  • 12.75'' Flexplate

    Note: Carburetor, spark plug wires, starter, oil filter and oil filter adapter, and exhaust manifolds are not included.



  • ______________

    StingrayJim
    NCM Lifetime Member #1936

    Stingray's '76���������������������������� StingrayJr's '78���������������������������Lil Red '94

    (click each one to see a bigger version)

    Reply-LockedReply-Locked
    Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
    Crate Engine or heads and cam (14/15)
     3/22/07 8:47am
    aceintheholeLifetime Member
    Lifetime Member
    Send Private Message

    Manteca, CA - USA

    Vette(s):
    1978,two tone,Metalic Rootbeer & gold 1975 L48 4 speed


    Joined: 11/20/2005
    Posts: 3623

    I bought 2 out of 3 of my vettes for less than the price of a ZZ4, but one can't help but lust for an extra 100 + horses under the hood. I'm hoping to go there myself some day, but that much money would buy a lot of improvements on the other cars.

    ______________

    Jimmy B.
    Just can't wait to get on the road again.

     
                                 Click to see larger views!

    Reply-LockedReply-Locked
    Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
    Crate Engine or heads and cam (15/15)
     3/23/07 6:48am
    frstvette
    Former Member

    Send Private Message

    Fresno, TX - USA

    Vette(s):
    1980 corvette


    Joined: 1/15/2007
    Posts: 240

    well guys im in the same boatUnhappy To start off with the good point, my dad gave me the 80 4speed vette. It has 80,000 miles on the rebuilt motor. I took off the intake to have it polished and looked inside the heads and saw build up around the bottom of the valves, now I want a new motor. Scared to bye allum heads, dont know  if seals will blow. The motor is not smoking or burning oil. should I just ride out the waves untile Im really able to afford a good motor?  

    ______________
      
    Reply-LockedReply-Locked
    Reply w/QuoteReply w/Quote-Locked
    Our Sponsors help support C3VR